Welcome to Healthshare's fresh new look! What's changed?

Healthshare - Australia's interactive health network

This question has been posted in these health communities: Weight Management

Q: Do the same principles apply for men and women when trying to shed excess kgs?

I'm tryng to shed about 8kgs. Do the same principles apply for men and women when trying to shed excess kgs?

Answer this question

Answers

  • Hi my name is Matt and I love health and fitness. I am a Personal Trainer from Sydney, Australia with many years experience in Australasia ... View profile
    Yes and no. Men need significantly more energy than women generally. There is a great formula known as the Harris Benedict Formula that gives calories to maintain, lose, and gain weight responsibly and sustainably according to ones weight, age, height and activity levels… Both men and women should do cardio and resistance training if they want to burn fat, instead of losing excess muscle in the process - afterall - who wants to look gaunt! Reply to this post  |  Report
    • Thanks Matt - useful info. Reply to this post  |  Report
  • I'm an Accredited Practising Dietitian and Nutritionist, consultant, author, speaker and food and health enthusiast. I love talking and writing about food and health. I ... View profile
    Pretty much, but the psychological approach needed can be very different. Women tend to have a more complicated and emotionally fraught relationship to food whereas men tend to be more problem and solution oriented.Women generally are more involved with food purchase, planning and preparation as well whereas many men eat whatever they're given! Attitudes to food, weight and dieting also tend to be different: many women experience poor body image whereas many blokes are obese but think they look fine. I'm generalising of course and everyone is different but I do think the approach to weight loss in men needs to be a bit different and I've written a book called Belly Busting for Blokes that I hope hits the spot. You can get it here http://www.greatideas.net.au/advanced_search_result.php?keywords=Belly+Busting&osCsid=8522a8b78d537a353a78a2821b6fbc55&x=28&y=5 Reply to this post  |  Report
  • Arlene is a registered practising dietitian, with a private practice in the Eastern Suburbs of Sydney, and has built a strong business over the last ... View profile
    The same principles apply to men and women. Energy in versus energy out. Eat regularly but make better choices and reduce your portion sizes, and partake in regular exercise. Reply to this post  |  Report